Middle East Construction News – Construction Week Online

Home / NEWS / Rera parking space rule hurts investors' pockets


Rera parking space rule hurts investors' pockets

by Paul Collett on Mar 18, 2009

  19 Comments
RSS Feeds Print this page

Residents are being forced to park outside the Crescent buildings because of the ruling.
Residents are being forced to park outside the Crescent buildings because of the ruling.
[More Images]

Click on more images (right) to see photos of the Crescent

Investors have come out in force to criticise new legislation by Dubai’s Real Estate Regulatory Authority (Rera) that stipulates residents must have a paid for car parking space with their property.

Since yesterday when ConstructionWeekOnline wrote about the new rule and how it is affecting investors of the Crescent development, in the International Media and Production Zone, scores more disgruntled investors have emailed or posted their comments online.

They say they weren’t informed about the rule, which specifies residents must buy a parking space in order to register with the Land Department. Failure to register will prevent them from renting or selling their property.

Kieran Donovan wrote online that he was forced by Damac to buy a parking space in the developer’s Lake View Tower, in Jumeirah Lake Towers.

“They wouldn’t even give me a handover until I went to the bank and got a manager’s cheque. I had to pay whatever was asked of me as I will be homeless next week and need to move into Lake View,” he wrote.

Similarly, Ami Dhadli wrote: “When I purchased, on my sales agreement it says optional. I didn’t buy parking at this time so why am I forced to buy now?”

However, one reader has stated that the ruling has since been withdrawn, further adding to confusion.

Investor Jerry Ascione, who bought his apartment in the Crescent in 2006 for US $164,000 (AED602,000), spoke exclusively to ConstructionWeekOnline yesterday.

“I’m over from the US checking on my studio apartment after handover,” he said. “This is all news to me. When I bought the place I asked Damac’s then facilities management representative if I needed to buy a parking space – he said no, I didn’t.

“As I don’t have a car here and spend the majority of my time in Florida, obviously I didn’t want to spend a further AED40,000 on a space.”

Story continues below
Advertisement

FEATURED COMMENT

Damac offer parking at a reasonable price?!?!?! First off the parking is not free hold, it is a license. Secondly, "a re

  19 Comments

Ascione says he’s now faced with a bill of up to $31,300 bill for a parking space.

“This is outrageous. First the price hike, and secondly the fact, as I understand it, is that if I don’t buy one I will not be able to register with the Land Registry, meaning I cannot legally sell or rent my apartment,” he said.

In response, Niall McLoughlin, Damac’s senior president, corporate communications, said: “The Dubai Land Department has recently issued all developers with a circular stating that it will not register any unit unless it has a paid for car parking space.

“This is a recent ruling by the Dubai Land Department and applies to all developers in Dubai, and we are caught in the middle.

“Fortunately Damac still has some parking spaces available. We are offering customers who did not originally buy a space with their units the opportunity to do so at an attractive rate, with pricing dependant on location.”

Rera has as yet been unavailable to comment.

Meanwhile, the chairman of Damac Hussain Sajwani said yesterday a new era had begun in the UAE real estate market - one in which investors would no longer be able to make "millions overnight".

- Are you an investor who has been affected by this ruling? Post your comments below.




Readers' Comments


Jerry Ascione (Feb 23, 2010)
Coral Springs
USA

DAMAC are bullies
Damac offer parking at a reasonable price?!?!?! First off the parking is not free hold, it is a license. Secondly, "a reasonable price?" Damac offered covered license parking at 115,000 AED!?!?!?! Now it is down to 30,000 AED?!?!? I'll wait until it is free, thanks. Damac continued to blame RERA and Dubai Land Development for their mistakes. Look at The Crescent in the IMPZ where I own a studio. The inside parking is barren. Only a small handful of investors who didn't read the contract bought parking and they are furious. Don't take my word on it though, go to The Crescent and see for yourself. Damac delayed NOC's until they expired from giving them to DLD and still hold a lot of investor money in escrow accounts gaining interest.

Gerhard (May 4, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Still parked-off, outside ...
It's now May, and residents are STILL not allowed to avail themselves of the parking facilities at DAMAC's The Crescent.

Bob (Mar 31, 2009) United Kingdom

Armada towers
Hi i live in the northeast of England,and have an apartment in Armada towers have been paying for the past 4 yaers. What a scam if you would like to contact me please e-mail haarlemhouse@hotmail.com

John (Mar 30, 2009)
Cape Town
South Africa

Parking
Why can you just park in the street? Surely even paid parking is cheaper than that price? By the way where do visitors park?

matthew cullen (Mar 26, 2009)
london
United Kingdom

car park rip off
hi i also got my unit back in 2004 and was never told that there would be requirement to have a car parking space before the handing over could be completed. there is no mention of this in my contract and as the build is 2 years behind do we as investors get any compensation on lost revenue? no, just a scandalous and unjust demand for more money. i think that this will send future investors running.

Bob (Mar 25, 2009) United Kingdom

Praking
I agree with Ray and think F.A. is talking a load of tosh

Ray (Mar 25, 2009) United Arab Emirates

Rera Parking Rule
Dear F.A. It's obvious that you are NOT familiar with the whole story. 1) At the time of purchase of the apartments, having a parking was OPTIONAL. 2) Price to purchase one was 20,000 AED (again OPTIONAL). If there was supposed to be a rule to have parking then they should have informed the buyers about this and not sold the units without parking! It's just pathetic that after 4 years, all of a sudden, they are forcing you to pay 120,000 AED, for parking. 3) Land department does not register any property without parking, that means, that you cannot have any Title Deed, meaning the propety is not officially in your name! 4) Shame on DAMAC & whoever is behind this scam...

F.A. (Mar 24, 2009)
RERA Parking Space Rule
Why people are complaining if you want to use the property then you don't need to register for selling or renting and therefore you dont have to buy parking space if you don't need it! However if you want to sell or especially rent your property its only fair to give it out with a parking space! This adds value to your investment! Unfortunately people in Dubai are Super greedy they want to make a lot of money and fast without giving anything out!!! Thank you RERA for controlling this.

Bob (Mar 23, 2009) United Kingdom

Armada Towers
My sales agreement also says parking OPTIONAL Now armadaholdings is asking 115,000 AED for parking bay. After 4 years this has to be the biggest SCAM to date

john (Mar 20, 2009) Canada

Parking space with condo
Thank you RERA...it only makes common sense that one space per unit be built (minimum) and assigned (still remains common space) and that the developer be compensated for it at purchase... let the owner lease it out as an investment... in Dubai there will always be a market for that!!! RERA IS RIGHT!!!

Paul Collett (Mar 19, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Rera parking bay rule hurts pockets
I'm currently trying to contact the relevant person at Rera for a definitive answer on the matter. However, he is not answering his mobile or replying to emails. Watch this space though, because we want an answer.

Caroline (Mar 19, 2009) United Kingdom

Parking rule
We purchased a 1 bed room app in the Armada development on JLT in 2004 and are also in the position where we are being forced to buy a parking space. The price which Armada are asking for a parking bay is minimum 115,000AED!!!!! I have sent an enquiry to Dubai Land Dept but am still awaiting a reply. I see from the comments that Dubai Land Dept are now saying that this has been withdrawn - has anybody else heard this or even better has anybody had it confirmed in writing????

Toofif (Mar 19, 2009)
London
United Kingdom

DAMAC = dishonest & corrupt
I bought in Lake View in 2004. Dealing with DAMAC is a nightmare - I would advise anyone thinking of purchasing from them to walk away; anyone with an off-plan or under-construction property to consider handing it back. The number of problems Lake View owners are having at handover is obscene. All of the handover problems are designed to bully more money out of Owners. The parking issue is just one of many, many issues. When I bought in 2004 I did buy parking for my unit. At the time, the only parking was underneath the tower (an important factor in Dubai's summer heat). Now DAMAC are saying that I must pay more to get parking under the tower and that my parking space is outside. And this is the least of the problems owners are facing.

Salman Ahmad (Mar 19, 2009)
Islamabad
Pakistan

Parking Space
I bought a studio in the Lake View Tower by DAMAC at JLT in 2004. At that time I was given a choice to buy a parking space with it but I declined due to budget constraint. Now after a very long and frustrating wait of over four years, when finally the time of handing over of my apartment has come, I am being informed that it is compulsory to buy a parking space! What is the Government thinking, do they want all investors to run? If at all this law is to be made then it should be for the new investors who could take into account their budget.

kurt barbian (Mar 18, 2009) Germany

Parking space rule
Met the Assistant Director General of Dubai Land Department last week and was told that this ruling has been withdrawn, hence no parking space would be required. But seemingly DAMAC has them all under control. It's scandalous and shameful and a total rip off. And whilst the press is seemingly paralyzed by DAMAC's influence the latter is luring more and more people into their trap. Very sad.

ami dhadli (Mar 18, 2009)
Nottingham
United Kingdom

parking rule by rera
when i purchased this, on my sales agreement it says optional. i didnt buy parking at this time so why am i forced to buy this now? it is not on my SPA agreement. the government should not change the rules for their own benefits

Hont (Mar 18, 2009) United Arab Emirates

Parking Space Fiasco
So the Dubai Government spends BILLIONS of dollars on a metro system to try and eliminate traffic congestion. However you cannot own a place unless you buy a car and a parking space. Nice one guys

Kieran Donovan (Mar 18, 2009)
Dubai
Ireland

Damac Fiasco
I have also just moved into a Damac Apartment- Lake View Tower and i have also had to pay for a parking bay.They wouldn even give me handover until i went to the bank got a Managers cheque and handed it to them!I had to pay whatever was asked of me as i will be homeless next week and need to move into Lake View. Damac make out they are caught in the middle but this is utter rubbish.Damacs number one priority is to get as much money from the buyer as possible.extra floor area,unknown fees.Handing over a good quality property is secondry to them. I eventually got my apartment handed over and similiarly to Gerhard- the apartment and building were not even finished!My apartment ceiling had Gypsium board missing,paint to walls not finished,AC not commissioned. This was the product i paid all my life savings for!Damac do not know the meaning of customer care.

Gerhard (Mar 18, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

The Crescent
What puzzles me is what the incentive is for Damac in enforcing this Rera ruling? Or is it just being civic-minded? Or, being behind schedule at The Crescent and strapped for cash as a whole, is there a possibility that Damac is just manipulating Rera law rather creatively to fill its rapidly-emptying coffers? I am a resident at The Crescent, and can certainly guarantee that my landlady in the UK is blissfully unaware of all these issues. The article also fails to mention that Damac has declared The Crescent 'ready' for occupation, when it clearly isn't: there's no air-con, there's a lot of teething problems with water and electricity in general, together with malfunctioning elevators, and none of the facilities or infrastructure alluded to by both Damac and the agents selling the apartments.


COMMENTS

Name *
Email *
City
Country
Subject: *
Comments: *
Math Question: *
Solve this simple math problem
and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
Refresh the image if not clear
Remember me on this computer



NEWSLETTER SUBSCRIPTION
Email:



Arabian Supply Chain Middle East
Hotelier Middle East
Digital Production Middle East
Arabian Oil and Gas Middle East
Construction Week Online - India
Utilities middle east\
Hotelier India
LinkedIn
CWO dotcom



Articles
Companies
ITP.com
Ahlan.ae Masala.ae Ahlanlive.com ArabianBusiness.com ArabianBusiness.com/Arabic ArabianBusiness.com/Jobs ArabianBusiness.com/Property ArabianOilandGas.com ArabianSupplyChain.com ArabianTravelDirectory.com ConstructionWeekOnline.com ConstructionWeekOnline.com DigitalProductionME.com Grazia.ae HotelierMiddleEast.com ITP.net TimeOutAbuDhabi.com TimeOutDubai.com TimeOutTickets.com Utilities-ME.com VivaMagazine.ae commsmea.com designmena.com