Middle East Construction News – Construction Week Online

Home / NEWS / HRW slams Al Habtoor over 'obscene' attitude


HRW slams Al Habtoor over 'obscene' attitude

by James Boley on Sep 6, 2009

  7 Comments
RSS Feeds Print this page

Workers from Al Habtoor went on strike last week over wages
Workers from Al Habtoor went on strike last week over wages

International human rights campaigners Human Rights Watch (HRW) has slammed Al Habtoor over their “obscene” attitude to their staff following a strike last week.

Last week, Al Habtoor managing director David Savage said, “The company is in the process of implementing a new productivity-based incentive scheme, whereby workers are rewarded for increased productivity as opposed to working longer hours. The new scheme is expected to result in workers increasing - not decreasing - their take-home pay.”

Speaking to Construction Week, HRW Middle East head of research Samer Muscati criticised Al Habtoor’s payment scheme and raised questions over the personal safety of its workers.

Story continues below
Advertisement

FEATURED COMMENT

The govt. should take some serious steps to monitor the construction companies in terms of wages payment,labour amenities, productivity issues,etc.

  7 Comments

“There is something a bit obscene with company bosses telling workers, who toil for long hours in the punishing summer heat of the Emirates for low wages, that they are just not sweating enough to justify higher pay,” said Muscati. “Al Habtoor’s proposal that workers work harder (or, as the company put it, increase productivity) could well result in an increase in the number of work-related accidents.”

Muscati was also concerned about the fate of the strike leaders. “We know that in the UAE, workers who attempt to organise, bargain collectively, or strike to demand their rights may face termination and deportation.”

A spokesperson for Al Habtoor said, "Al Habtoor disagrees with the comments of Human Rights Watch. The company continuously reviews the employment contract conditions – including accommodation - of its workforce. Our ability to attract and retain a high quality workforce is an important element of the company’s success."
 




Readers' Comments


Clarence S Lewis (Sep 13, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

HRW slams Al Habtoor over 'obscene' attitude
The govt. should take some serious steps to monitor the construction companies in terms of wages payment,labour amenities, productivity issues,etc. In most of the cases because of their influential nature, all these issues are brushed aside.

Mark (Sep 13, 2009)
DXB
United Arab Emirates

Al Habtoor Labour treatment
Mr Savage can you please deifne productivity and the conditions at in which you need to acheive. How well are you treating your workers.Will he say what he said to his own contrymen( westerner).This is explotation of the labourers from the subcontinent and Asia. if anyone speaks for his rights they are considered as trouble makers amd deported.

John (Sep 12, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Corporate corruption
Leighton construction is pretending to be one of the competetive company in more than three or four countries. In fact this is on the verge of bankruptcy. There are many flaws in the interim management and execution and given as follows: 1. Leighton has lost all of its project not only outa emirates but also in abu dhabi. This is only because of the lack of managing aptitude among the leaders. 2. This company lost sama dubai project too. and it also revelas its week management and dealing with firms. 3. The dome of Sorbone University setles down during construction. That event also revelas the wekness in execution & quality management of the company although company has so many white quality managers. 4. Management of the company talks about the productivity measurement of the dailywages labourers when the time coes to afford them the sufficient number of hours as overtime to survive in this hipe condition of dubai. What about its staffs? after loosing business, loosing projects everywhere and in the presence of abovementioned condition its staffs are getting bonus and incentives. How company is assessing their productivity? The poor worker are harassed. This is an excellent example of Corporate corruption.

Nawaz Ahmed (Sep 7, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

HRW comment on Al Habtoor
Al Habtoor as a contractor are notorious for their treatment of their labour force, they get away from all this HR abuse, due to their influence with the labour department, individual complaints are just brushed aside and the person is either summarily sacked and or warned to keep his mouth shut.

george thomas (Sep 7, 2009)
Human Rights Watch
Rather than punish poor workers, why does the Dubai Government not punish big construction companies whose continued abuse of their staff has been primarily responsible for the bad publicity Dubai gets from abroad. These rich construction bosses are dragging the name of Dubai and the UAE through the mud. And all in the name of greed. Don't blame the workers. Don't blame the International Press. Blame those rich bosses who continue to put their personal interests before the interests of their own country. As Holy Ramadan is a time of reflection for Muslims, and as charity is a fundamental tenent of the great Islamic Faith, perhaps it is not too late for construction bosses to reflect on their actions and to show some charity to their workers - who also just happen to be fellow human beings and children of Almighty Allah.

Mike (Sep 7, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Productivity Bonuses
I think that the attainability of the productivity bonuses needs to be examined first before images of increased hardship are portrayed.Surely getting overtime is not a right! Any work has to be measured by results not by numbers of workers or hours present!

Paul (Sep 6, 2009)
Dubai

'Continuous review'
I'd imagine the 'continuous review' of contract conditions has probably involved some sort of one-way flight for the strike leaders.


COMMENTS

Name *
Email *
City
Country
Subject: *
Comments: *
Math Question: *
Solve this simple math problem
and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
Refresh the image if not clear
Remember me on this computer



NEWSLETTER SUBSCRIPTION
Email:



Arabian Supply Chain Middle East
Hotelier Middle East
Digital Production Middle East
Arabian Oil and Gas Middle East
Construction Week Online - India
Utilities middle east\
Hotelier India
LinkedIn
CWO dotcom

RELATED ARTICLES





Articles
Companies
ITP.com
Ahlan.ae Masala.ae Ahlanlive.com ArabianBusiness.com ArabianBusiness.com/Arabic ArabianBusiness.com/Jobs ArabianBusiness.com/Property ArabianOilandGas.com ArabianSupplyChain.com ArabianTravelDirectory.com ConstructionWeekOnline.com ConstructionWeekOnline.com DigitalProductionME.com Grazia.ae HotelierMiddleEast.com ITP.net TimeOutAbuDhabi.com TimeOutDubai.com TimeOutTickets.com Utilities-ME.com VivaMagazine.ae commsmea.com designmena.com