Middle East Construction News – Construction Week Online

Home / NEWS / Disgruntled investors storm Rera office


Disgruntled investors storm Rera office

by James Boley on Oct 21, 2009

  40 Comments
RSS Feeds Print this page

Investors are unhappy with delays and specification changes on Vue de Lac
Investors are unhappy with delays and specification changes on Vue de Lac

A group of around 30 investors turned up at the Real Estate Regulatory Agency (Rera) Tuesday morning to file a case over ongoing delays and specification changes at the Vue de Lac and Vista del Lago developments.

Investors on the Al Attar project at Jumeirah Lake Towers accused the developer of unreasonable delays and changes being made to apartments without the consent of owners.

“We have been promised the project since then end of 2007. It was then pushed to 2008, then the end of 2008, and now he’s saying 2011 – which will never happen, because up to date they’ve only finished the piling,” said investor Makram Mohamed.

Story continues below
Advertisement

FEATURED COMMENT

Hi, Anyone having news on THE WIND TOWER II project refunds ??

  40 Comments

Many asserted that apartment specifications have changed so drastically that they no longer wish to purchase property in the project and want a full refund.

Investors are unhappy at what was described in a letter from Al Attar as “some small changes”, where two-bedroom apartments have been changed to one-bedroom ones.

Al Attar had revised the prices of the apartments in line with the reduction in apartment size, but investors said that they had bought two-bedroom apartments specifically and a smaller alternative was not acceptable.

“Because of the change of designation and all of this delay, we don’t want this property any more. The majority of people investing were buying to live in this property. Ninety per cent of our group wanted to live in this. Now they’ve changed the designation, we don’t need it. I bought a two-bedroom; you can’t give me a one-bed plus study,” said investor Shailendra Sainani.

“The majority of us need our money refunded and the costs absorbed. [Al Attar] needs to resell the project from the beginning.”

In addition to changes in designation, many investors are also concerned that delays to the project will result in a huge interest bill arising from finance agreements that can only be concluded following apartment handover.

Some investors took out finance agreements in 2006 under the impression that the project would be handed over in 2008. They are now facing the prospect of paying five years’ worth of interest on finance agreements, should the project be delivered according to a new completion date of 2011.

Some investors also query Al Attar’s ability to deliver the project on time.

“Can we still believe Al Attar can deliver in 2011, if they couldn’t even start construction in the last three years?” said one investor.

The group has filed a case with Rera because they say that Al Attar Properties is refusing to communicate with them except through a lawyer.

No-one from Al Attar was able to comment on the case or development.

The case has now been filed with Rera, who said a decision on the steps it would take would be forthcoming in the next few days.




Readers' Comments


Mohammad Qureshi (Jun 27, 2011)
The Wind Tower II
Hi, Anyone having news on THE WIND TOWER II project refunds ??

LKhan (Apr 14, 2011)
Apex suites
USA

refund
how to find legal help?

amanda (Apr 8, 2011)
herts
United Kingdom

group action
hi we brought in international city ,we have been told you cannot take class action and it is a civil matter but we have started a group with around 100 investors ,best you do the same ,its easier to get lawers to sit up and listen as a group ,my project is on hold ,rera dosent listen just forward you to dubai courts amanda

LKhan (Feb 28, 2011)
Apex suites
USA

Minc and refunds
Now that we are getting together, lets go onto facebook, all 5500 of us. Please startMinc sold my apt . and kept my money,do not send them money.

LKhan (Feb 10, 2011)
Apex suites
USA

refunds to real estate
The government should take over the developers and make things right, with our hard earned money, the developers will repay the government with interest and get their buildings back. God help us. Lk

LKhan (Feb 8, 2011)
Apex suites
USA

refund
They started taking money 06 , then bank said no money left in account, so no refund, The spt was sold to another and Minc used my money, REra where. only allah knows

LKhan (Feb 8, 2011)
Apex suites
USA

refunds to real estate
Rera does not speak to people , only to the developers, The wolf, watching the hens?

LKhan (Feb 8, 2011)
Apex suites
USA

Non refund
If we are to do any good, we will have to get on to face book ,and do what egypt did, the world knows and dubai might get anxious?

n/a (Jan 29, 2011)
London
United Kingdom

Al Attar - international city - global point
I purchased from Al Attar in June 2006. I have been asking for a refund since. Hardly next to nothing built, I paid an installment for Global Point International City.

AF (Dec 9, 2010)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Feirouz 2 project by Azizi in Al Furjan
Hi Does any one have any status of Al feirouz 2 project in Al Furjan

Margret (Dec 8, 2010)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Invest in your own country unless you want to get FOOLED
Don't get fooled - I was taken for a good ride with 3 of my projects. Invest in your own country

Margret (Dec 8, 2010)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

RERA - Get into action
Give reasonable solutions to the investors.

Jane (Jun 1, 2010)
Birmingham
United Kingdom

Re: Al Attar Development
Al Attar never had a genuine intentions to build any of these projects from start. They used the investors fund to develop their own projects. In Economic Term This is known as "Al Attar Free Financing Scheme". The best way for investors to get their money back would be to: 1) Arrange an action group (there are hundreds if not thousands of dissatisfied/cheated on investors) by asking the investors in these failed projects to get together. Creation of a web site toward this goals with investors email addresses would be a good start. 2) Collectively approach RERA to file the case against Al Attar. 3) Invite local Media (i.e. The National and Emirates Business 24/7) to report the case. 4) Use social media to express your experience with Al Attar. 5) As Action group stay cohesive and together (as Al Attar have used the policy of devide and rule for long time) 6) It is my understanding that the case is very similar if not identical to "Al Boom" case; however, it is a shame that this has gone quiet for such a long period.

John Robertson (May 27, 2010)
Lytham St Annes
United Kingdom

RERA LAWS
I have just com of the phone with RERA complaining about Al Attar Toronto Towers asking them to to ask Al Attar to return our money as Al Attar do not answer my emails or phone calls. RERA say I have to employ a lawyer to get my money back but we do not have the money to employ a lawyer and who is to say we will get any money back? RERA is a joke. Has anybody successfully sued Al Attar yet? If so, what did it cost? I think it is time to gather together and go in force to RERA against AL ATTAR.

John Robertson (May 27, 2010)
Lytham St Annes
United Kingdom

Al Attar Toronto Tower
We also bought off plan from Al Attar and paid all the installments on time expecting our apartment to be ready 2007 it is still not started we have been on to RERA three times complaining but they do not help it is about time that they started honouring their commitment to the ordinary working person who work hard to save their money to buy an apartment only to be robbed from by Al Attar RERA has been advertised as to help and make it safer for people to invest in Dubai but once again they are not honouring their commitments

Francesco (Dec 4, 2009)
dubai

VISTA DEL LAGO
We know very well what happening to the project Vista del Lago..we should coordinate an action all together to understand more regarding the project please let me know and keep in touch for any update

James J O\' Sullivan (Nov 18, 2009)
Cork
Ireland

Al Attar - Toronto Tower
It is clear at this stage that investors are treated with total comtempt by this company. Business is built on reputation and trust. I await positive action to rectify this crisis, alas, with little faith.

Duna (Oct 26, 2009)
Dubai

How come?
WHen you buy something, anything at all, you agree to certain terms, if any of those terms are changed without your approval it should be your right to break the contract and get your money back. We are talking here about apartments not just any other small purchase. As far as I can tell, time to dilever has been changed with out buyer's approval, so has some specifications of the appartments themselves and the cost as most are financed, so this all says one thing, developers are certainly not supplying what was agreed on and there fore options should be given to investors to reduce their losses. Please RERA help them and set some ground rules and limits for developers in general and their ability to change the development and contract. Thank you.

Dima (Oct 26, 2009)
Take Action
I think RERA should take action to protect the small investors who are buying such units from big developers. It is a shame for Dubai name to be dragged into those kinds of problems, as Dubai is a beautiful place to live in and RERA should protect the buyers to encourage more people to buy and invest in Dubai.

Omi (Oct 25, 2009)
Dubai

RERA it's up to you now
I'm hoping that RERA moves on this quickly and makes an exmaple of Al Alttar! Their actions are shameful and illegal and I really hope RERA, who's real interest is supposed to be protecting the investors, acts quickly and decisively to ensure that Al Attar pays for their actions.

Sami Shafi (Oct 25, 2009)
Dubai
Afghanistan

RERA must act
RERA must stop being a coward and take action against Al Attar. I would recommend that all investors gather together for a peaceful protest in front of Al Attar building to protest this.

Matt (Oct 25, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Al Attar
If you've invested with Al Attar, then say goodbye to your money. They have not even able to pay their subcontractors or suppliers for ages, how could they develop these properties, or even pay investors back. In a regulated environment, they would have been bankrupt ages ago.

MLS (Oct 25, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

investing in Dubai
These actions by a supposedly reputable property developer and are completely unacceptable and would not happen anywhere else in the world. I hope that RERA can come to the aid of these people and help to demonstrate that Dubai is a same place to invest.

Sara (Oct 24, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Unbelivable!
Seriously?! If all these 'investors' were contractually bound with Amlak that means that they were actual end users! Not some money seekers willing to dumb their units at the chance of a little profit! It's sad to see that the land of opportunity has come to this. This is hard earned money. Invested in what should be beneficial to the economy - Real Estate! I hope RERA would do something to stop this nonsense!

muhammad (Oct 22, 2009)
London
United Kingdom

Shame on Al-attar & RERA
Al-Attar already canceled two projects (Vancouver Tower and Toronto Tower in International city) last year. They have two towers Polaris and Regal Tower in Business Bay sold three years ago but construction is halted + three towers in JLT not constructed yet. Al-Attar used all investors money in the construction of non-free hold tower on Sheikh Zayed Road is in finishing stage. Its a day Robbery. RERA is one of the reason of property downfall in Dubai. Instead of protecting investor, they are protecting cheater developers like Al-Attar properties.This issue is the test of RERA !

Anirudh (Oct 22, 2009)
Abu Dhabi
United Arab Emirates

Test Case for RERA
This is really a test case for RERA to prove they are really serious in protecting the investors from the clutches of so called high headed Developers, who think they can take any body for the ride.It is high time for RERA to act to instill confidence in investors especially the expat community Come On RERA Take the challange!!!!

Amanda Maginn (Oct 22, 2009)
Luton
United Kingdom

Al Attar
I bought almost 5 years ago with Al Attar, Toronto Tower, not a single brick laid since 2005, it wasn't even for investment but for a holiday apartment for me, my daughter and husband. Al Attar wont return our emails/calls and have made false promise after false promise. They have taken 25k of our hard earned cash, which I doubt we'll ever see again. I don't believe they had any intention of building in the first place. Have made two complaints to RERA with no reply. It's a sham out there, when are they going to step in and act on Al Attar and what they have done to us, we are just one of hundreds.

AlexT (Oct 22, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Not the only ones.Elite Residence Anyone
Can anyone tells if there is anyone in a position to do anything about any of these. RERA is over it's head as it is, maybe the can open a forum on it's projects page and let the "owners/buyers" (the so call investors are long gone) express their concerns directly and openly to RERA, I know I'm dreaming.... Take Tameers's Elite Residence, due for delivery Oct.2009 now "due" for "completion" Nov. 2011 there are on Slab 10 of 90 floors and instead of apologies to their clients they are claiming 65% completion/payment!!!!!!!!! apparently with the blessings of RERA. What are the other "owners" of this development have to say? Would love to know.

Simon (Oct 22, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Investing in Dubai ? are you mad !!
Dubai not just shoots itself in the foot it manages to aim at its head to .... talk about killing the goose that lays the golden egg, this is slaughtering to the investors confidence. Oh why oh why would anyone put their money in UAE Real Estate ....

Nina (Oct 21, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Jokes that's not funny !
Dubai or RERA must change the current regulations of allowing developers to delay their projects without any penalty. Investors in UAE are at the TOTAL MERCY of developers with the blessing of RERA. We can't even cancel the purchase contract due to non delivery of units as per agreement. The developer can cancel and still retain big percentage of our investments even if it's no fault of ours. RERA must set a guideline to developers to complete their project within stipulated period with an allowance of reasonable delay but not years. If they are unable to meet the deadline then they should be penalize and investors should have the option of waiting or getting the full refund with interest.

Kamran (Oct 21, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Investors are the foundation
The law should protect investors, because they are the one who pay for any development, but it seems that Real Estate Market in Dubai is there to build at the cost of investors, which is a very short term and misguided approach. Dubai boom was mainly because of investors confidence and if that is lost, no government or developer can fuel the developments. So this is a test case for RERA to prove that they consider the interest of investors seriously, and protect others not at their cost.

BD (Oct 21, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

A disgrace all around
Unbelievable that this sort of thing is all too common here. How can anyone with a shred of common financial sense consider an "investment" in Dubai real estate in the foreseeable future when there are so many other more compelling investment opportunities in jurisdictions where the rule of law exists. However, I must also admit that I cringe whenever I hear the people who plunked their money down on this type of deal as an "investor". This is not investing, it is at best gambling and trying to get in on the ponzi scheme that was the real estate boom before it was too late and not to be "the greatest fool" in doing so. Unfortunately although there is always a greater fool willing to pay an even more ridiculous price for an asset until the bubble bursts, it is the greatest fools who are left holding the bag. Sad situation but one that has many parallels in the history of asset bubbles.

Raed (Oct 21, 2009)
Al Ain
United Arab Emirates

Al Attar K1 K3 JLT project
This is a test for RERA to show how they are protecting investors in realestate sector in Dubai! According to what RERA will do in such case I will decide weither or not to invest more in Dubai.

NK (Oct 21, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Good opportunity for RERA to prove their power to attact investors to the country!
If RERA can prove that they protect the investors by getting them compensation from developer in this particular case (as the fault is definitely at developer side), I am sure the investor confidence in the country will boost up and Dubai can attact more foreign investments. Eagerly awaiting to see the action that RERA takes on this...

Mohammed (Oct 21, 2009)
DUBAI
United Arab Emirates

Al Attar Properties - JLT project - Vista Del Lago / Vue De Lac
What a shame? Al Attar properties has brought on Dubai. Whatever efforts are being put by the government to build the brand "DUBAI" some mean unhuman businessmen are spoiling it for a mere benefit. Because of Al Attar investors are losing confidence & afraid of such delays, loss of money & irresponsible behaviour. Who is going to resolve their problem- Is it RERA, COURT, GOVERNMENT ? Its still not clear & such developers are left to openly exploit, cheat, use investor's money for other businesses & ruin the lifes of people. I think its not late due to such bad developers, some investors who lost their hard earn money will start commiting suicides in Dubai. Its a test for RERA & Government to step in & resolve this matter & restore the confidence of investors in Dubai. As everyone knows word of mouth spreads across borders, the investors who stormed RERA office will not leave any effort to fight against the corrupt Al Attar. I wonder how Al Attar can sleep with so many people are crying who are victims to his cheating / sins.If anybody really cares for DUBAI please stand up against such fraud developers like Al Attar & do not buy or do business with them.

soni (Oct 21, 2009)
dubai
United Arab Emirates

Does anyone care??
we are talking about salaried people who have invested their hard earned money to buy a roof over their heads. the investors who were in it for the kill have made their monies and vanished. people with intentions of living in these apartments are left in the lurch. there is no flat, the money is stuck and they continue to pay rents.

Peter (Oct 21, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

JLT
This will be a test for the real estate laws of the country, and would either make or break the confidence of investors and buyers who would like to invest in UAE real estate and would like to have a second home. Assume if somebody who bought a house to stay and loses a million in premium and interest, will he/she will be ever able to have confidence in investing in this market ???

Marlow (Oct 21, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

Simple fact...
... it is increasingly clear that some developers simply regard their businesses as outside the law, or even just common sense. The project is clearly on hold, probably because of a lack of cash, and once again investors are left powerless.

Martin Williams (Oct 21, 2009)
Good
I thought group complaints were not possible with Rera?? Anyone know??

Schilling (Oct 21, 2009)
Dubai
United Arab Emirates

What a shame!
What a shame! This developer did not start a project that was due for delivery in 2008 and RERA did not cancel the project? A 2BR made into a 1BR? Are you serious? And they didn't take the consent of the owners? Seriously? You must be joking! And the developer hasn't been blacklisted? Now that's why I didn't believe in buying property in Dubai. Laws change by the minute and this is a good example of contracts made void by new laws. Wouldn't happen in any other part of the world.


COMMENTS

Name *
Email *
City
Country
Subject: *
Comments: *
Math Question: *
Solve this simple math problem
and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
Refresh the image if not clear
Remember me on this computer



NEWSLETTER SUBSCRIPTION
Email:



Arabian Supply Chain Middle East
Hotelier Middle East
Digital Production Middle East
Arabian Oil and Gas Middle East
Construction Week Online - India
Utilities middle east\
Hotelier India
LinkedIn
CWO dotcom

RELATED ARTICLES





Articles
Companies
ITP.com
Ahlan.ae Masala.ae Ahlanlive.com ArabianBusiness.com ArabianBusiness.com/Arabic ArabianBusiness.com/Jobs ArabianBusiness.com/Property ArabianOilandGas.com ArabianSupplyChain.com ArabianTravelDirectory.com ConstructionWeekOnline.com ConstructionWeekOnline.com DigitalProductionME.com Grazia.ae HotelierMiddleEast.com ITP.net TimeOutAbuDhabi.com TimeOutDubai.com TimeOutTickets.com Utilities-ME.com VivaMagazine.ae commsmea.com designmena.com